Have you ever wondered why some people, despite their best intentions, keep repeating the same destructive patterns of behavior? The irony of life is that it is often the most deeply hidden traumas that determine our most visible behaviors. Psychodynamics, a theory born from Freud's thought and developed by his followers, offers a fascinating perspective on these unconscious forces that shape our personality and can lead to disorders when defense mechanisms fail.
We live in a world where diagnostic labels often obscure the person behind them. Borderline, narcissism, avoidant personality disorder – these terms have become part of everyday language, but do we really understand what lies behind these terms? What if these disorders were not character flaws, but adaptations to traumatic experiences? A psychodynamic approach to personality disorders allows us to look deeper, beyond the symptoms, for unresolved internal conflicts and relational patterns that are often invisible at first glance.
In this article, we will take you on a journey through the unconscious territories of the psyche, showing how early relationships with caregivers, defense mechanisms, and psychological conflicts can lead to the development of personality disorders. We will discover why trying to change behaviors without understanding their deeper roots is like treating flu symptoms without fighting the virus. Isn’t it fascinating that what seems like irrational behavior can have deep rational roots in the perspective of a person’s inner world? By following the path of psychodynamic understanding, you will gain not only theoretical knowledge, but above all new tools for empathetic understanding of both others and yourself.
Theoretical foundations of the psychodynamic approach
The psychodynamic approach is based on 3 key pillars theoretical, which have shaped the contemporary understanding of the human psyche. The first is the unconscious – a fundamental concept introduced by Freud, indicating the existence of mental processes inaccessible to consciousness. The second pillar is the theory of drives, describing the motivational forces that drive human behavior. The third element is the structural model of personality, dividing the psyche into the id, ego and superego.
In the course of the development of psychodynamic thought, the number of 5 stages of psychosexual development proposed by Freud. This theory assumes that difficulties experienced at any of the stages can lead to fixation and affect the functioning of the personality in adulthood. The oral, anal, phallic, latency and genital stages constitute a sequence through which each individual passes, shaping their relationship patterns and defense mechanisms.
The contemporary psychodynamic approach has evolved significantly since Freud's time, integrating 7 different schools of thought. From ego psychology, through object relations theory, self psychology, to intersubjective thinking, each school has made significant contributions to understanding human mental disorders. In particular, Bowlby's attachment theory, pointing to the fundamental importance of early relationships, has revolutionized thinking about the etiology of personality disorders and provided an empirical basis for therapeutic interventions.
Defense mechanisms in personality disorders
Defense mechanisms are unconscious psychological strategies, which help protect our psyche from fear, shame and other painful emotions. In personality disorders, these mechanisms are often overused and rigid, which paradoxically leads to deepening problems instead of solving them. Recognizing your own defense mechanisms is the first step to mental health!
In borderline personality disorder, fission – the world is perceived in black and white, with no grey areas. Narcissistic people often use idealization and devaluation to protect their fragile sense of self-worth. Change is possible! Therapy helps you recognize these patterns and replace them with healthier ways of dealing with reality.
Working with defense mechanisms requires courage and patience. Every step towards understanding your own patterns is a victory. Remember that defense mechanisms were once necessary—they were created to protect you. Now you can learn new, more adaptive ways to cope with challenges. Living consciously without rigid defenses is possible!
Psychodynamic diagnosis of the main types of personality disorders
Autumn, with its characteristic decline in solar energy and shortening of daylight hours, is a time that reflects particularly clearly some of the mechanisms observed in personality disorders. Psychodynamic approach for diagnosing personality disorders draws attention to internal conflicts, defenses, and object relationships, which are particularly evident during periods of change and transition – like this time of year. People with borderline personality disorder may experience more intense emotional instability along with the decrease in social activity typical of autumn, which intensifies their fear of abandonment.
In the case of narcissistic personality disorder, the autumnal sense of loss (symbolized by falling leaves) may intensify unconscious defense mechanisms against depressive feelings of inadequacy. As Otto Kernberg has noted, "The narcissistic personality structure is a defense against early childhood conflicts and splitting experiences" – these processes may intensify during autumn melancholy, when external confirmations of values become less frequent.
Schizoid and avoidant personality disorders also exhibit seasonal fluctuations, as the autumn-winter period promotes social withdrawal and isolation, which can mask pathological relational patterns and complicate differential diagnosis. In a psychodynamic approach, it is crucial to understand that unconscious conflicts lie behind observable behaviors, and autumn, with its natural tendency to reflect and turn inward, provides unique therapeutic opportunities for working with these mechanisms.
The Process of Psychodynamic Therapy in the Treatment of Personality Disorders
Until 75% of patients with personality disorders experiences significant improvement in functioning after long-term psychodynamic therapy, making it one of the most effective methods of treating these complex disorders. However, the therapeutic process is neither simple nor short-term – it requires systematic work on deeply rooted patterns of thinking, feeling and behaving, which often date back to early childhood.
Psychodynamic therapy for personality disorders is based on the assumption that unconscious conflicts and past experiences shape the patient's present difficulties. As Freud stated: "The unconscious is the true psychic reality; in its innermost nature it is as unknown to us as the reality of the external world"The therapeutic process involves gradually becoming aware of these hidden contents and defense mechanisms, which enables working through difficult experiences and changing dysfunctional patterns.
In the case of personality disorders, the therapeutic relationship is crucial, as it is a microcosm of the patient’s relationship with the outside world. By analyzing the transference—that is, the projection of feelings and expectations from important people from the past onto the therapist—the patient can understand his or her repetitive interpersonal patterns. The therapist, remaining neutral but empathetic, helps the patient recognize these patterns, understand their sources, and gradually introduce more adaptive ways of functioning.
The process of psychodynamic therapy includes the following stages:
- Building a Trusting Therapeutic Alliance
- Identifying unconscious conflicts and defense mechanisms
- Working through past traumatic experiences
- Developing more adaptive patterns of thinking and behavior
- Integration of new experiences and insights into a coherent self-image
It should be emphasized that psychodynamic therapy is a long-term process, lasting from one to several years, depending on the depth of the disorder and the individual needs of the patient. Unlike behavioral therapies, which focus on the rapid elimination of symptoms, the psychodynamic approach aims at a deep, structural change of personality, which takes time but leads to more lasting therapeutic effects and improved quality of life.
Challenges and difficulties in therapeutic work
Therapeutic work is full of many challenges that a therapist encounters every day. Misunderstandings, patient resistance, difficult emotions – these are just the beginning of a long list of obstacles.
Transference and countertransference are particularly complex phenomena in psychodynamic therapy. When a patient transfers onto the therapist feelings related to important figures from the past, the therapist must remain alert and aware of his or her own emotional reactions. The ability to recognize and manage one's own emotions is a fundamental tool in the therapist's arsenal., without which the therapeutic process can be disrupted or stopped. The challenge becomes even more demanding when the patient presents with personality disorder features, which increases the intensity of transference phenomena.
Burnout affects many therapists.
Working with a patient's trauma is a special challenge that requires gentleness and specialist preparation. The therapist must balance empathetic engagement with maintaining an appropriate distance that protects both him and the patient. Traumatic experiences discussed during the session can lead to secondary traumatization of the therapist if he does not take care of proper mental hygiene. Supervision, self-therapy and appropriate education in the field of working with trauma are essential elements of burnout prevention., especially in the context of working with people experiencing profound personality disorders and serious developmental traumas.
Ethical boundaries are another area of potential difficulty. Maintaining professional boundaries while building an authentic therapeutic relationship requires constant reflection and self-awareness. Ethical dilemmas often have no easy solutions and require the therapist not only to know the code of ethics but also to have deep inner honesty and the courage to make difficult decisions.
Effectiveness of the psychodynamic approach – a review of research
The psychodynamic approach, despite its long history and wide clinical use, has been criticized for decades for the lack of solid empirical evidence to support its effectiveness. However, systematic reviews of research from the last two decades significantly changed this picture, providing ample evidence for the effectiveness of psychodynamic psychotherapy in treating various personality disorders. The meta-analysis by Leichsenring and Leibing (2003) showed that long-term psychodynamic therapy leads to statistically and clinically significant changes in patients with severe personality disorders.
Particularly promising results have been obtained in studies on the effectiveness of psychodynamic psychotherapy in the treatment of borderline personality. Randomized clinical trials comparing psychoanalytic mentalization therapy (MBT) with standard treatment have shown that the psychodynamic approach significantly reduces suicidal behavior, self-harm, and the number of hospitalizations. Moreover, the therapeutic effects were maintained in follow-up studies conducted 5 and 8 years after the end of therapy, which indicates the durability of changes achieved within the psychodynamic approach.
It is worth emphasizing that the effectiveness of the psychodynamic approach is not limited to specific types of personality disorders. As Shedler (2010) notes in his groundbreaking article “The Efficacy of Psychodynamic Psychotherapy”, the effect size of psychodynamic therapy is at least comparable to other forms of therapy, and in some cases even exceeds them. Unlike cognitive-behavioral therapy, the benefits of psychodynamic therapy not only persist after treatment ends but are often strengthened, suggesting that patients internalize the therapeutic processes and continue psychological work even after the formal end of therapy.
Modern research on the effectiveness of psychodynamic therapy uses advanced methodologies, including brain imaging, to shed light on the neurobiological basis of observed changes. Research by Karlsson’s team (2010) has shown that effective psychodynamic psychotherapy leads to measurable changes in the activity of the prefrontal cortex and limbic system, brain areas involved in emotion regulation and the ability to reflect on one’s own and other people’s mental states. These neurobiological correlates of effective psychodynamic therapy provide a strong argument for the biological grounding of psychodynamic mechanisms of change, addressing earlier criticisms of the unscientific nature of this approach.
A New Perspective: Psychodynamics as the Key to Understanding Yourself
As we have seen, the psychodynamic approach to personality disorders offers a deeper understanding of human functioning that goes beyond simple diagnostic classifications. We have analyzed how early experiences shape personality structures, how defense mechanisms protect against anxiety, and how unconscious conflicts influence our everyday behavior.
Paradoxically, although personality disorders may seem like an insurmountable barrier, the psychodynamic perspective shows their functionality – they are an adaptation to difficult life experiences. It is here that we observe narrative coherence effect – our deep need to create a meaningful story about ourselves, even when that story is painful or dysfunctional.
Understanding your own narrative is the first step to rewriting it.
The narrative coherence effect explains why it is so hard to change patterns of behavior – they threaten our sense of identity. However, the psychodynamic approach allows us to see that our stories are not written in stone – they can be reinterpreted and transformed.
What can you do right now?
- Reflect on recurring patterns in your relationships
- Seek professional support in exploring your life story
- Keep a journal of moments of strong emotional reactions
- Be patient – changing personality structures is a process, not a one-time event
Remember that psychodynamic understanding is not reserved solely for those diagnosed with a personality disorder – each of us can benefit from deeper insight into our own motives.
Frequently asked questions
What are the main defense mechanisms found in personality disorders according to the psychodynamic approach?
In the psychodynamic approach, personality disorders are characterized by specific defense mechanisms, such as projection, splitting, denial, and projective identification. Some might argue that these are merely theoretical constructs, but clinical research consistently confirms their presence in the clinical picture of individual disorders.
Is psychodynamic therapy effective in treating all types of personality disorders?
Psychodynamic therapy has shown varying effectiveness depending on the specific type of personality disorder, being particularly effective for borderline and narcissistic personality disorders. Critics may point to the longer duration of this form of therapy, but longitudinal studies document more lasting effects of treatment compared to short-term interventions.
How do early childhood experiences influence the development of personality disorders according to psychodynamic theory?
Psychodynamic theory emphasizes that traumatic experiences, disruptions in relationships with caregivers, and unresolved conflicts in early childhood can lead to dysfunctional personality patterns. Although some researchers emphasize the role of genetic factors, the psychodynamic approach convincingly documents how early attachment relationships shape later intrapsychic and interpersonal functioning.
What is transference and countertransference in the therapy of personality disorders?
Transference is a phenomenon in which the patient projects his or her feelings, attitudes, and expectations from past relationships onto the therapist, while countertransference concerns the therapist's emotional reactions to the patient. It could be argued that these are unnecessary complications of the therapeutic process, but in fact their analysis is a key tool for understanding and working through the deep relational patterns of the person with a personality disorder.
English 
Polish